Top 10 Most Valuable Nickels to Your Coin Collection 

#10 1927-S Buffalo Nickel Value: $125,350

#9 1918-S Buffalo Nickel Value: $125,350

#8 1867 Shield Nickel–Proof With Rays Value: $132,250

#7 1867 Shield Nickel–Proof With Rays Value

#6 1917-S Buffalo Nickel Value

#5 1913-D Buffalo Nickel–Type 2 Value

#4 1916 Buffalo Nickel–Doubled Die Obverse Value

#3 1926-S Buffalo Nickel Value

#2 1913 Liberty Nickel–The Olsen Specimen Value

#1 1918 7-D Buffalo Nickel–Doubled Die Obverse Value

10 of the Buffalo Indian Nickel Values